Newmanor-contractor-goes-bust

When a contractor goes bust, should development lenders back the scheme or enforce? 

Newsletter sign-up

Sign up to our newsletter to receive updates on our latest news for lenders, landlords, occupiers and developers.

Name
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

A development lender advances money against a programme it expects to be built to budget and on time. However, if the main contractor fails part-way through the build, that expectation falls away, and the scheme is very likely to cost considerably more and take considerably longer to finish. The lender typically has no contract with the contractor, yet the value of its security, the timing of its repayment and the borrower’s ability to perform all depend on the building being completed. So what should it do when the contractor fails: support the existing developer through a recovery, change who controls the project, or enforce its security and take matters into its own hands?

Insolvency Service figures show 3,873 construction company insolvencies in England and Wales in the 12 months to September 2026, more than in any other sector. Not every one of those businesses was a main contractor on a funded scheme, and the numbers say nothing about the likelihood of any particular contractor failing, but they show why contractor failure is a material risk development lenders need to plan for rather than hoping for the best. Much has been written about how developers should respond when a contractor fails. This article looks at the same event from the lender’s side, and how a lender chooses the best way to protect its position when every available option carries additional cost and risk.

The original appraisal may no longer work

A development loan is underwritten against an appraisal. It assumes a construction cost, a programme, a gross development value and a profit margin for the developer, and the lender sizes its facility so that there is headroom between the debt and the value of the completed scheme. Contractor failure disturbs every part of that calculation.

Replacing a contractor midway through a build is expensive. A new contractor inherits work it did not carry out, often with incomplete records and uncertain quality. It will want to investigate before it prices, and some of the existing work may need to be opened up, corrected or redesigned. On design and build schemes, someone must pick up the design responsibility that sat with the failed contractor. The replacement will price for the risk of taking on another firm’s work, and some contractors will refuse to accept liability for it at all. Subcontractors left unpaid may return only on better terms. Meanwhile the site must be secured and insured, interest continues to run, and sales or lettings move further away.

The developer’s profit is usually the first casualty. Additional costs come out of the margin before they reach the lender, so a scheme can absorb a significant overrun and still repay the debt in full. That cushion can disappear entirely, though, and once it has gone two things change. The lender’s headroom starts to erode, and the developer’s reason for persevering weakens. A developer that can see no return from the project may be less willing to put in more equity, give further guarantees or commit management time to a difficult recovery. That is not always how it plays out. A developer with personal guarantees at stake, substantial equity already in the scheme or a reputation to protect may be determined to finish even without a profit, and that determination can be valuable to a lender, provided it is backed by resources and a realistic plan.

This is why it is important to separate two questions that are easily run together. One is whether the project remains commercially viable for the developer. The other is whether the lender can still recover its money. A scheme that no longer makes a profit may still be worth completing from the lender’s point of view, and a scheme the developer is determined to finish may not repay the lender in full.

Establishing the true financial position

No sound decision can be taken without a reliable picture of where the project stands, and much of that information will come through the borrower and the funder’s own advisers. In the early days, a lender will want confirmation that the contractor’s insolvency has been verified and that the borrower is following the termination procedure in the building contract correctly. Terminating on the wrong basis, or before the contractual definition of insolvency has been met, can leave the developer facing a claim of its own. Many facility agreements also require the lender’s consent before the building contract is terminated or a replacement appointed, which provides an early opportunity to influence events.

The lender will also want to know that the site, materials, design information and construction records have been secured, that construction insurance remains in place, and which subcontractors are willing to continue. Any proposal to pay subcontractors directly to keep critical trades on site needs care, because a poorly structured arrangement can leave the developer paying twice for the same work.

It helps, too, to be clear about whose rights are whose. Some protections are held by the lender directly, such as collateral warranties and direct agreements in its favour, and bonds or guarantees under which it is a named beneficiary. Others belong to the borrower, principally its rights under the building contract, and the lender’s interest in them comes through the security assignment it took when the loan was made. The extent to which the lender can exercise or control those rights depends on the terms of its security and the circumstances in which those rights become enforceable.

Alongside this, the monitoring surveyor should assess the value and quality of work completed, identify defects and produce an independent estimate of the revised cost and time to complete. That estimate should capture remedial work, the new contractor’s preliminaries and risk pricing, additional professional fees and surveys, insurance, legal costs and the extended cost of finance. An updated valuation should address both the site in its current state and the completed scheme at the revised completion date, recognising that the market may have moved.

With those inputs, it becomes possible to test the loan against its loan-to-value, loan-to-cost and loan-to-gross-development-value covenants, check the adequacy of the interest reserve and contingency, compare the revised programme with the final repayment date, and size any funding gap. The next step is to identify every potential source of money to fill that gap, including sponsor equity, cost overrun and completion guarantees, claims under performance bonds and parent company guarantees, and any recovery from the insolvent contractor’s estate. Bonds and guarantees need prompt attention, because claims are commonly subject to strict notice requirements and expiry dates, and conditional bonds may be capped well below the true cost of completion.

Will the finished building be fundable and saleable?

A question that is easy to overlook is whether completing the building will produce an asset that a buyer, tenant or refinancing lender will accept. A scheme can be physically finished but in many cases the quality of the product could be compromised. Units may remain difficult to sell or refinance, especially if the construction and warranty package behind it is incomplete.

Rights against the failed contractor are worth less once it is insolvent, but they are not necessarily worthless. Depending on the facts, the contractor may have insurance cover that can be pursued, and claims may lie against solvent subcontractors and consultants under collateral warranties or other direct rights. Those avenues need to be identified and preserved early. Warranties from the professional team and key subcontractors, particularly those with step-in rights and rights to use the design, become far more important once the main contractor has gone.

The lender also needs to understand what protection the replacement contractor will offer. A new contractor may be unwilling or unable to provide a performance bond, parent company guarantee or collateral warranties on the terms the original package provided, and it may resist responsibility for the interface between existing and new work. If neither the failed contractor nor its replacement stands behind part of the building, that risk stays with the developer, and it may ultimately affect the lender through additional costs, reduced security value and uncertainty over its exit. Structural warranty providers and latent defects insurers will also need to be satisfied about work carried out before the change of contractor. The replacement contractor’s own financial standing deserves the same scrutiny as the original appointment, because a contractor that is financially weak, or that wins the job on a price it cannot sustain, could leave the scheme facing a second failure. All of this makes the shape and strength of the replacement package directly relevant to any decision to advance further funds.

Higher-risk buildings in England bring an additional layer. A change of principal contractor or principal designer must be notified to the Building Safety Regulator. That notification normally includes a compliance declaration from the outgoing dutyholder, which may be difficult to obtain from a contractor that is now insolvent. The regulations allow for this by requiring the client to explain the steps it took to obtain the declaration, so its absence does not prevent the change, but the gap in the record still needs to be managed. Design changes needed to complete the scheme may fall within the change control regime, under which major changes require approval before the related work can start. Those steps need to be reflected in the revised programme and cost to complete.

A default does not mean enforcement is the right answer

Contractor failure will often give rise to a right to act. The facility agreement may treat the contractor’s insolvency or the termination of the building contract as an event of default in its own right. Even where it does not, cost increases and delays frequently lead to breaches of financial covenants, cost overrun provisions or the longstop completion date. Some facilities give the borrower a defined period to appoint an acceptable replacement contractor before the position becomes a default, and some give limited cure rights, for example by prepaying part of the loan to restore a covenant ratio or providing further security. The precise wording matters.

Having a right to enforce is not the same as deciding to enforce, and it helps to treat the response as a series of separate decisions. The first is whether a default has occurred and how it should be recorded. A second is whether to stop further advances. Depending on the terms of the facility agreement, a lender may be entitled to withhold further drawdowns while it assesses the position, without immediately accelerating the loan or enforcing its security. The third, and most significant, is whether to accelerate and enforce.

These steps do not have to happen together. A lender can identify a default, reserve its rights and pause funding while giving the borrower a fixed period to produce a credible recovery plan. Formal standstill arrangements can provide a structured window with agreed milestones and the right to enforce if they are missed. Informal accommodation is where the risk lies. Continuing to fund, accepting late performance or negotiating at length can, depending on the facts, give rise to arguments that a default has been waived or the loan varied. A well-drafted reservation of rights letter helps, but it is not a complete answer if the lender’s later conduct points the other way, so its actions need to stay consistent with the position it has reserved. Any waiver or amendment should be documented precisely so that the lender gives up only what it intends to.

Enforcement can also damage recovery. Appointing receivers over a part-built site may trigger termination rights for off-plan purchasers, pre-let tenants or forward funders. It brings its own professional costs and timescales, and it can mean selling an incomplete asset into a market that will discount heavily for the uncertainty. A clear legal entitlement to enforce is a reason to consider enforcement, not a reason to choose it.

Back the developer, bring in someone new, or take control?

Once the financial position is clear, the question becomes which route is likely to return the most money, net of any further funding, after allowing for the time it will take and what could still go wrong.

A simple comparison shows how this works in practice. Suppose that selling the part-built site now would leave a substantial shortfall on the loan, while the monitoring surveyor’s figures suggest that a further advance to fund completion would allow the debt to be repaid in full. On those figures, funding completion looks the better option for the lender, even though the developer may expect to make no profit at all. The answer can change quickly if the completion estimate is uncertain. A further overrun, a longer programme or a fall in completed values could leave the lender with a larger exposure and a shortfall no smaller than the one it would have accepted on an immediate sale. Testing the revised appraisal against those downside cases is often what separates a sound decision to fund completion from an optimistic one.

Keeping the existing developer in place preserves its knowledge of the site, the planning position, the design and the professional team, and avoids the disruption of a formal process. It works best where the developer is competent, financially resilient and prepared to commit further equity or guarantees, and where a suitable replacement contractor is available on acceptable terms. The danger is lending more to a borrower that cannot deliver. A lender taking this route will usually want approval of the replacement contractor, its building contract and its security package, together with a restructured facility carrying revised covenants and repayment dates, appropriate pricing and fees, additional security and tighter conditions on further drawdowns.

Where the scheme remains viable but the developer’s management is the weakness, support can be made conditional on appointing an independent development manager with real authority over the recovery. That adds cost and will not cure a problem that is fundamentally financial, but it can avoid the value lost through enforcement.

If the sponsor lacks the resources or appetite to continue, a consensual transfer to a new developer, or the introduction of a development partner, may preserve more value than a formal process. Such arrangements take time to negotiate, may need third-party consents, and a new partner will expect a share of the upside that would otherwise go towards repaying the lender. Depending on the market, a refinancing by another funder or a sale of the loan may also be available.

Where completion is uneconomic or further funding cannot be justified, enforcing and selling the site as it stands may be the most rational outcome. Lenders commonly enforce through receivers appointed over the property, or through administrators where the security package allows, rather than taking possession directly. A sale crystallises the position relatively quickly, but at a price likely to reflect a substantial discount for the incomplete works, the weakened warranty position and the buyer’s own completion risk.

Alternatively, the lender may enforce and then complete the scheme under the control of receivers or administrators, or with a development manager appointed for that purpose. This can produce a better recovery where the completed value comfortably exceeds the cost of finishing, but it means committing further capital, taking on construction and market risk, and staying exposed for longer.

Where experienced loan management earns its keep

Much of a lender’s protection comes down to how critically it reads the borrower’s recovery plan. A revised programme and budget will often assume that a replacement contractor can mobilise quickly, that subcontractors will return on their original terms, that remedial work will be limited and that sales values will hold. Each of those assumptions may prove optimistic. An experienced loan management team, supported by advisers who have seen how contractor recoveries actually unfold, will test them rather than accept the revised budget at face value. It will want to see what sits behind each figure, such as tender returns from prospective replacement contractors, confirmation from key subcontractors, intrusive surveys of the existing work and current market evidence for values.

That same experience helps a lender recognise when support for the existing developer has run its course. Reluctance to commit further equity, budgets that keep moving, difficulty attracting a credible contractor, a professional team losing confidence in its client, and information that arrives late or incomplete are each a reason for concern. Taken together, they often point towards a change of control or enforcement.

Lenders who pick up the early signs of contractor distress, such as slipping programmes, valuation disputes, falling labour numbers on site, unpaid subcontractors and requests for advance payments, have more room to manoeuvre. Instructing advisers at that stage allows time to review the documents, reserve rights properly and prepare for each possible route before the contractor stops work, rather than making those decisions under pressure.

A balanced conclusion

A contractor insolvency does not dictate the outcome for a development lender, but it does shorten the time available to make good decisions. Establishing the real cost and value of the scheme, checking that the finished building will be saleable and fundable, keeping legal options open, and testing every recovery plan against what could still go wrong will put a lender in the best position to choose between backing the developer, bringing in someone new and taking control.